Subfloor repair
Fixing the board is the easy part. Finding out why it got wet or soft comes first.
Subfloor repair means replacing or reinforcing the sheet layer under your flooring when it has gone soft, swollen or loose. A small patch is often enough. Whether it lasts depends on what made it fail.
This page prints no prices and does not recommend a brand or a company. It helps you work out what you are looking at.
How to tell the subfloor is the problem
Soft spots, a spongy feel underfoot, squeaks that get worse, and flooring that lifts or cups all point down. Look from below if you can reach it, in a basement or crawl space. A dark, crumbling or stained underside means moisture has been there for a while. See subfloor water damage for the patterns.
Why subfloors fail
Nearly always it is water. A plumbing leak, a damp crawl space or condensation on the underside will soften plywood and boards over time. Fixing the board without stopping the water just repeats the repair.
When a patch is enough
If the damage is limited to one area, the framing below is firm and the moisture source is gone and dry, cutting out the bad section and fastening new sheet to solid joists is a normal repair. The key word is dry. New wood over damp framing will not last.
When it is a bigger problem
Check the joists and the sill plate under the soft area. If they are soft, split or rotted, you are no longer dealing with the subfloor. Floor joist repair and sill plate rot cover what that means.
A screwdriver test, with limits
Pressing a screwdriver into a joist end shows whether the wood is firm. That tells you whether to worry. It does not tell you what to do. Anything that carries the floor is not a do-it-yourself job when it is damaged, and a licensed structural engineer should look at it.
Dry the space before you close it up
If the underside is a damp crawl space, the fix is as much about the ground as the floor. Cover bare soil, deal with standing water, and let the wood dry out before new sheet goes on. Rules on repairs and permits vary by state and city, so ask your local building department.
Frequently asked questions
What is a subfloor?
The structural sheet layer under your finished flooring, fixed to the joists.
What causes a subfloor to go soft?
Almost always moisture, from a leak, a damp crawl space or condensation underneath.
Can I patch just one section?
Often yes, if the joists are sound and the moisture source is gone and dry.
How do I know if the joists are damaged?
Soft, split or crumbling wood under the soft spot is a sign. A licensed structural engineer should assess it.
Do I need a permit?
Rules are local. Your building department can tell you.
Sources
What this page explains is based on these official sources. If you check one and it does not match what you read here, send it to us and the article gets corrected.