Replacing a floor joist
Most damaged joists can be reinforced instead of replaced. Replacement is the exception, and it is not a weekend project.
Replacing a floor joist means taking out a damaged board that carries the floor and putting a new one in its place. And it is structural work that a licensed structural engineer should specify. The floor above rests on that board. So a mistake shows up as a sag, a crack or worse.
This page prints no prices and does not recommend a brand or a company. It explains the idea so you can follow what a professional proposes. It is not a set of instructions.
When replacement comes up
A joist is usually only replaced when large sections are rotted, crushed, burned or cut through. Wood that is stained but still hard can often be dried and left alone. A joist with a long split or a big notch near the middle is a different story. Press a screwdriver tip into the wood: if it sinks in easily, the fibers are gone.
Reinforcing is often chosen first
Many repairs add a new board beside the old one instead of removing it. That approach is called sistering, and you can read about it in sistering floor joists. Replacement makes sense when the old board is too far gone to carry anything, or when it is in the way of the fix.
Why this is not a DIY job
Removing a joist takes its share of the load off the floor. Temporary supports have to carry the weight while the work goes on, and where they go depends on the framing. Cutting out a joist without that planning can let the floor drop or crack finishes above. This is the reason the work is left to qualified people.
Find the cause first
A new joist will rot too if the damp that rotted the old one is still there. Check the soil, the vapor barrier, plumbing leaks and the ventilation first. Floor joist repair covers how the causes and the fixes fit together.
How to approach a proposal
Ask for the plan in writing: which joists, why, and what holds the floor up in the meantime. Get the engineer's assessment from someone who does not sell the repair. Your local building department can tell you whether a permit and an inspection apply where you live, because the rules are set locally.
Frequently asked questions
What does replacing a floor joist involve?
Supporting the floor temporarily, removing the damaged board and fitting a new one that carries the load. A licensed structural engineer should specify the work.
Can I replace a floor joist myself?
This guide does not give instructions for it. The floor above depends on the joist, so the work should be planned and signed off by a licensed structural engineer.
Is replacing a joist better than sistering?
Not necessarily. Sistering is often enough. Replacement is for joists too damaged to carry anything or ones that are in the way of the repair.
How do I know if a joist is too rotted to keep?
If a screwdriver tip sinks in easily, or the wood is crumbly, split or crushed, ask an engineer to assess it.
Do I need a permit to replace a joist?
It depends on where you live. Ask your local building department, since permit rules are set locally.
Sources
What this page explains is based on these official sources. If you check one and it does not match what you read here, send it to us and the article gets corrected.